Should runners be allowed to listen to music during races?
Read the latest on the subject from the New York Times.
Thank you all SO much for your comments, and now I brace myself for a loss in readership as I give my opinion: Running with music is a personal choice. When it’s not allowed, it’s not allowed. But if I were deciding if it were allowed, I’d probably permit it.
For me, the case against music isn’t strong enough. Individuals can make good cases for why they choose not to listen to music while they run (and I agree with most all of those reasons), but I don’t buy into the idea that someone listening to music is infringing on the running enjoyment of others — especially no more than an inconsiderate person without headphones.
I think people are drawing false correlations between music and bad behavior (i.e. being oblivious to others or dangers when running, being disruptive to others).
Let’s start here: Volume is adjustable, and not everyone sets the volume too high. Complaints that runners with headphones can’t hear people around them only applies to people listening to their music too loud. Complaints that runners with headphones impose their tune selection on others only applies to people listening to their music too loud. (And if that’s an issue, should we ban talkative runners and people who breathe heavily or clomp their feet as they run?)
The finish line argument (and similarly starting instructions) is a decent one. Yep, if people are listening to their music, they might not be listening to race officials. But again, it’s not an argument that applies only to people with headphones. Plenty of runners are so tired at a finish that they’re oblivious to instructions. Most finish line photos I take show people stopping their watches as they cross the line. They’re already preoccupied with a different type of device. And lots of people ignore starting instructions because they’re talking, stretching or generally rude.
I don’t think I’ve ever listened to music while racing, but I do wear my iPod with the Nike sensor on my arm so I can review my pace post-race. I could get splits on a watch, but that requires math, and if there’s a tool to help us English majors, great. I’d be bummed if that was outlawed. Technically, I’m wearing an iPod. I’m just not listening to it.
The ability to listen to music or other audio content while running is expanding our sport. It’s added the touch of fun or multi-tasking that some people needed. Maybe they’re not your people, but that doesn’t make them wrong.
On the most basic level, I support Music (yes, with a capital M). Music has, for ages, moved us emotionally and physically. Why can’t running be another form of dance to music? Since I can’t find a reason that others shouldn’t be allowed to mix art and sport, I support it.
And where do races with bands or music along the course fit into this conversation…?